Henri the Haussmann Apartment Owner, elevator customer

section 3 paris jun 27 2022 scaled.jpg
Photo: Peter Winters, 153 Paul-Vaillant-Couturier Avenue in Gentilly (Paris), June 27 2022

Actor #3: The Customer

Customer, actor – Henri the Haussmann Apartment Owner

As an innovation gets more widespread adoption, there can become a tipping point in which the old world has gone, and prospective customers need to consider what this means for them. Their purchase decision is around the value and financial value of buying the innovation, and what will happen if they do not buy it.

Let’s consider one such customer; a Haussmann Apartment Owner in Paris during the Belle Époque (1871-1914). To represent such a customer, we will create an imaginary character called Henri. Henri would have a decision about whether, or not, to install an elevator in his apartment building. It would be a B2B purchase, with Henri now operating in a market where Parisian tenants could choose between Haussmann apartments with or without an elevator as their place to live.

At the start of the Second Empire in 1852, Emperor Napoleon III laid out his grand vision for Paris. His most extensive public works program, known as Haussmann’s Renovation, was in transforming central Paris into a city of wide boulevards lined by smart apartments of a standard design. The Haussmann apartments were typically six floors high. For Parisians of the 1860s, the choice was not between building types but between floors with extra effort required effort to climb to the higher floors. Given this, the Haussmann apartments were designed for the lower floors to be more valuable according to a set pattern. Notice that classic “6 floor” Haussmann apartments have 7 levels with the sixth floor and mezzanine being “half-size”.

  • Sixth floor: Designed as the servant’s quarters or “chambre de bonne” with smaller rooms and lower ceilings.
  • Fifth floor: Designed for modest households.
  • Fourth floor: Designed for middle class or “petty bourgeoisie”.
  • Third floor: Designed for middle class or “petty bourgeoisie”.
  • Second floor: Known as the noble floor and considered the most prestigious level. It has the most elaborate decorations and largest rooms.
  • ‘First’ floor: Includes both a ground floor level for business and shopkeepers with a mezzanine for storage.

After 1870, property owners could invest in the installation of elevators in Haussmann apartments as this made these buildings more valuable. It enabled residents to enjoy the views from the higher floors without the effort of climbing the stairs.  The wealthiest residents of Paris would now tend to choose the fifth floor of apartments with elevators, the highest floor with comfortable rooms.

What is not so intuitively obvious is what happened to Haussmann apartments which remained without elevators. Property owners who chose not to install elevators now had properties which had become less valuable. Their wealthiest residents abandoned the noble floor on these properties in favour of the higher floors of those apartments with elevators. The apartments without elevators would now be relatively more appealing to younger people without families who do not mind climbing the stairs to enjoy the views from the higher floors. One can imagine that increasing numbers of younger people going up and down the stairs of these apartments could make lower floor apartments more noisy and less appealing. Gone are the days when the rich on the noble floor could tell the servants living on higher floors to be quiet or take an alternative staircase!

So, Henri would need to consider what type of tenants he would like to attract to his apartment block. These would be his customer value segments. Would Henri like to invest in an elevator to attract the wealthiest tenants, or make it more suitable for younger, active tenants?

What is critical is that Henri recognise that the world has changed and consider market information accordingly. Sometimes customers do not recognize this destabilization. To this point, a 2017 study by Meilleursagents included a survey of 10,000 respondents which asked about where they would prefer to live in a 6-floor apartment. With a lift, most would prefer to live on the 6th floor, and without a lift the most popular response was for the 2nd floor. Yet this does not represent the world as it now is. It is asking respondents to consider the apartment without a lift as though the option with a lift was not available.

In modern Paris, real-world data shows that:

  • Today, 60% of Paris’s buildings are in Haussmann design.
  • There is an approximately equal split between Haussmann apartments with and without elevators.
  • The fifth floor of Haussmann apartments with elevators is priced roughly 20% more than the second (noble) floor.
  • In buildings without elevators, the more expensive apartments are on the higher floors with the most expensive typically located on the fourth floor. This offers a balance of the benefits of higher floors without the effort of climbing all the stairs to the top.
  • An apartment on the fifth floor without an elevator is priced around 10 to 15% less compared to the same property with an elevator.

Customer, building – Apartment Building in Gentilly (Paris)

After 1870, elevator technology changed how architects designed buildings and not just for those with elevators.

Built in the early 20th century, the Haussmann-style apartment building at 153 Paul-Vaillant-Couturier Avenue, Gentilly is where the author rented a 4th floor room for a year in his early twenties. It does not have an elevator.

There are 6 levels to the building with the first level comprising a convenience store (now “Votre Marché Gentilly”) and an apartment for the concierge. Each window of the five floors above that have individual balconies with wrought iron railings. The second level has decorative brickwork indicative of it being the noble floor. To a lesser extent, the sixth level has some distinctive designs, presumably to signify it being the floor of the chambre de bonne.

There are a couple of ways that buildings such as this one have been impacted by the advent of elevator technology – the stairway design and the height of the floors.

To the first point, original Haussmann apartments would typically have had two stairways – the grand “escalier d’honneur” which ran from the main entrance to the noble floor and the better apartments; and the “escalier de service”, running to the top-floor service rooms and servants apartments. With the advent of elevators, staircases and the route of the elevators were no longer such an important feature of the building. This building in Gentilly had just one stairway, located in the centre of the apartment block.

The other difference from the original Haussmann form is to do with the standardization of height between floors. All the floors above the first level are of the same height. The first floor appears to be a bit taller than the other floors but does not have a ground floor and mezzanine level. One reason for this standardization is that since the noble floor was no longer the most desirable floor there was no reason to make it grander and taller than other floors. Also, it would make it easier to install elevators if the floors were the same height. One challenge for retrofitting elevators in the original Haussmann apartments was with how to manage the differences in floor height. Specifically, each floor would need to be at the same height, or higher than the elevator car. Given the lower height of the first floor and sixth floors some of these buildings have retrofit elevators which start one floor up or end one floor before the top.

These design changes can be observed in other cities. In New York these apartment blocks without elevators are called “walk-ups”, such as the 6-floor building used as the setting for the TV Series Friends.


References

  • In Living in Style: Paris Apartments for Rent in Iconic Haussmann Buildings, Amazing Architecture (2024), “Today, 60% of Paris’s buildings are in Haussmann design”. As a result of elevators “an apartment on the fifth level of a Parisian Haussmannian building is now priced roughly 20% more than the second floor, which is considered the noble floor”.
  • An article by 56 Paris Real Estate about “How Floor Level Affects Paris Apartment Prices (2023) discussed a study which “shows that in buildings without an elevator, the most expensive apartments are typically located on the fourth floor, rather than the top floor. This is because the fourth floor offers a balance of accessibility and privacy, without the inconvenience of climbing all the stairs right to the top.” In addition, “Modern estimates suggest that only a portion of Haussmann buildings have elevators at all (roughly around half, varying by arrondissement), and many of those installations have been modernized for safety and accessibility.”

  • In Haussmann Apartments in Paris: The Complete Buying Guide (2025) by Jean Mascla, Founder of Home Select, writes “The elevator, incidentally, is a decisive criterion. An apartment on the fifth floor without an elevator suffers a 10 to 15% discount compared to the same property with an elevator.”

     

  • In What Is Haussmann Architecture? (2022) by Kristin Hohenadel in The Spruce “(Today, some buildings have retro-fit elevators that may start one floor up or end one floor before the top, depending on the building layout.)”

     

  • In Paris Real Estate: Which Floor Is Best In Apartment Buildings? (2017) by Paris Property Group describes “A study by Meilleursagents looked at 50,000 transactions and interviewed 10,000 people and 5,000 agencies in an effort to determine once and for all the effect of floor on apart property value. A pdf summary of the results from this study is available.