John Jacob Astor III, elevator visionary

section 2 new york dec 10 2025.jpeg
Photo: Peter Winters, Colonnade Row (LaGrange Terrace) in New York, December 10 2025

Actor #2: The Visionary

Visionary, actor – John Jacob Astor III

It is very common that what makes an innovation successful is that it provides value in ways which are not anticipated, or even imagined, by the innovators. This is where visionaries can be so important to the success of an innovation.

Once such visionary was John Jacob Astor III (1822-1890), a wealthy man who came from a family with substantial real estate holdings in Manhattan. John Jacob Astor III was part of the network of visionaries who would transform New York in the decades following Elisha Otis’ safety elevator demonstration at The Exhibition of the Industry of all Nations.

In May 1854, John Jacob Astor III was 31 years old and, with his wife and young son, possibly still living at No. 424 La Grange Terrace. This was one of nine row houses which formed this terrace on La Fayette Place, located a few streets east of Washington Square. Opposite this home was the Astor Library Building, opened by his father a few months earlier, on January 9 1854, and to which John Jacob Astor III would become a life-long supporter.

The inherited wealth of John Jacob Astor III had come from his father and grandfather. As the population of Manhattan had grown substantially in the first half of the 19th century, so had buildings been developed ever northwards – and the Astor’s real estate holdings followed this geographical trend. Midtown was being planned in the 1850s, with Central Park approved by the city in 1853. The Crystal Palace, on West 42nd Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, was close to the northern perimeter of building development in Manhattan at this time.

It would seem highly likely that John Jacob Astor III would have visited the New York Crystal Palace Exhibition at some point during the 16 months it was open. If he did so, given his wealth, we might guess that he would have got there using his own personal carriage. Yet he might have considered going by horse-drawn omnibus as there was a large network of lines which had the Palace as their newest, and often northern most, destination. A recent innovation were horse-drawn railways which gave a smooth passenger experience. The first horse-drawn railway route, opened in 1852, ran along Sixth Avenue and terminated at the Crystal Palace on 42nd Street.

Did John Jacob Astor III see Otis Elevators during a visit to the Crystal Palace, amongst the 4,399 other exhibitors? Whether or not he did, he would soon become aware of Otis Elevators and how valuable this innovation would be for him and his family.

In 1854, as a continuation of how the Astor estate had been grown, John Jacob Astor III would naturally have been thinking about how they could be further expanded horizontally (northwards). Over time he would realize the value of expanding his real estate holdings vertically.

In 1857, it was at a property owned by the Astors that the first commercial passenger elevator was installed. It was a steam-powered lift installed within the E.V. Haughwout Building, a five-story department store located at 488 Broadway, less than a mile away from La Grange Terrace. This first elevator was used to make access within the store more convenient for staff and customers, especially to the upper floors. Yet the main value driver for adoption was its novelty value where the financial justification was based on increased store traffic and sales. Elisha Otis was paid US$300 for installing this elevator.

A key event occurred in 1870 with the opening of the Equitable Life Assurance Building at what is now 120 Broadway. This was for an eight-story structure and the first time that an office building was designed with passenger elevators in mind. It triggered the era of high-rise buildings and a change of real estate economics where upper floors became the most valuable. The year 1870 marked the start of the elevator age. In the major capitals of the world, any building developed after this date would have the technology of elevators in mind.

The creation of the new urban landscape of New York took time. In addition to requiring greater sophistication of elevators, it also required innovation around building construction. It needed the use of iron beams held together by rivets to act as a skeleton to strengthen building structures. After 1880, it benefitted from the use of electricity rather than gas for lighting.

Imagine John Jacob Astor III in 1875 at the time that he inherited the Astor estate on the death of his father. How would he be thinking about the value proposition of Otis elevators and how they could be justified financially? Presumably it would be something like this:

“With Otis elevators, my customers (who have leases on my properties) would find movement around their building easier for both people and materials, increasing the value to tenants and the price they would be willing to pay. Tenants would also pay more for the higher levels of the building (previously the least valuable); and this would increase with the tallest buildings which would attract the wealthiest tenants willing to pay for a panorama view. Higher buildings would also lead to a higher density of users for a particular parcel of land. My financial value is that if my customers are successful, they will be more able to pay me. Over the longer term my income from these properties will increase and the land will be more valuable if I do wish to sell.”

During the 1880s, John Jacob Astor III was the largest private owner of real estate in the city. He continued to grow the value of these holdings and became one of the wealthiest individuals in America.

The 1890s was a decade of marked acceleration in the construction of tall buildings in New York which would not have been possible without elevators. After John Jacob Astor III’s death in 1890, much of the control of his real estate ultimately passed to his nephew, John Jacob Astor IV (1864-1912) who was personally involved in a number of high-rise building projects in New York, notably the Astoria Hotel. In 1897 it was combined with the Waldorf hotel to become the Waldorf‑Astoria, one of the best‑known hotels in the world. It was claimed to be the first hotel to have electricity on every floor, with 18 electric elevators serving the building from sub-basement to the roof.

Such taller prestige hotels were starting to be built in other cities. One was the Chateau Laurier in Ottawa, commissioned in 1909 by Charles Melville Hays (1856-1912), president of the Grand Trunk Railway.

It is intriguing to think about much the Astors were influencers amongst their contemporaries and how this might have impacted the adoption of elevators. In social settings, one can imagine John Jacob Astor IV and Charles Melville Hays talking about their hotels and swapping notes about how elevators had impacted their design. Perhaps they did just that whilst they were both first class passengers on the Titanic, with Hays travelling back from London for the gala opening of the Chateau Laurier. Tragically, both John Jacob Astor IV and Charles Melville Hays would perish with the Titanic.

 

Visionary, building – Colonnade Row (LaGrange Terrace)

La Grange Terrace is one of the few remaining buildings left in New York from the era before elevators.

La Grange Terrace on La Fayette Place, later LaGrange Terrace on Lafayette Street (for reasons we will come to), was built in 1833 in the Greek Revival Style on land owned by John Jacob Astor. In the 1840s and 1850s, La Grange Terrace was one of the most exclusive addresses in New York. This is where the Astors, Vanderbilts and other members of the New York aristocracy lived.

To New Yorkers it also became known as Colonnade Row due to the Corinthian columns which spanned the second and third floors. In this era before elevators, and as with similar houses in New York of this period, the raised parlor floor, one flight above the sidewalk, was designed as the principle public suite. Typically, the parlor floor had tall ceilings around 12–13 ft floor‑to‑floor, with slightly lower bedroom floors above of around 10-11 ft. On Colonnade Row, those on the parlor floor would have access to the balcony and to the base of those columns.

La Fayette Place was named after The Marquis de La Fayette (1757-1834). Born into a noble family in France, as a young man he had come to America during the American Revolutionary War to fight against the British, leading Continental Army troops in the Batte of Yorktown (1781). From this campaign he became a lifelong friend of George Washington. They were both fellow Freemasons, and in 1784, La Fayette presented George Washington with a silk Masonic apron, depicting Masonic symbols and both the new flag of the United States and the flag of France. In 1790, La Fayette sent George Washington the key from the Bastille as a symbol of the triumph of liberty over tyranny.

The “de La Fayette” form of his name is associated with French nobility as it originally referred to rights over a seigneurial estate. Whilst he never formally changed his name from La Fayette to Lafayette (he and others used both spellings), during the French Revolutionary period it was more in the spirit of the times to use the single word “Lafayette” to downplay his aristocratic credentials. It also worked more easily with anglicized usage. His son remained a ‘de La Fayette’ who he named Georges Washington de La Fayette (1779-1849), which helped to further enhance Lafayette’s popularity in America.

Lafayette made a grand tour of the US in 1824-1825 to a rapturous public reception, including in New York, and it was after this tour that the first John Jacob Astor (who was also a prominent Freemason) named La Fayette Place in his honor. La Grange Terrace was likewise named after Lafayette’s French country estate, Château de la Grange.

In descriptions about Colonnade Row there has been inconsistent usage of the names La Fayette/Lafayette/LaFayette and La Grange/LaGrange, so it is necessary to refer to primary sources to understand how the names evolved. The original plans from ca.1830 show the area as La Fayette Place.

A contemporary early print shows how the building looked soon after construction, with the title “LA GRANGE TERRACE – LA FAYETTE PLACE”.

la grange terrace picture.jpg

In the Letts’s 1886 map of New York city, LA FAYETTE PLACE is shown (in relatively large capital letters) running between Great Jones Street (in smaller font with capitalized first letters) and 8th Street.

new york (letts, 1886) during elevator transformation
Detail from Letts’s 1886 map of New York, showing LA FAYETTE PLACE
nyc map 1886 acquired from kitty print
Letts’s 1886 map of New York, acquired from Kitty Print in February 2026

This naming of La Fayette Place in the older aristocratic form was in line with the sympathies of the Astors. Caroline Schermerhorn Astor (1830-1908), sister-in-law of John Jacob Astor III and mother of John Jacob Astor IV, was “the Mrs. Astor” who was central in codifying and policing what was known as an “American aristocracy” in Gilded Age New York. She determined the exclusive list of 400 people who could fit into her 5th Avenue ballroom, and that idea has a modern expression in the Forbes 400 list of most wealthy Americans. William Waldorf Astor (1848-1919), only son of John Jacob Astor III, moved to England in 1891 and became Viscount Astor in 1917.

In the early 1900s, the city cut through the dead end of La Fayette Place to make it part of a continuous artery running to the south of Manhattan. La Fayette Place, and this entire new road, was renamed Lafayette Street. Yet the naming transition was not just to do with the change from “a place” to “a street”. A New York Times article from 1902 referred to Colonnade Row as being “in Lafayette Place”. Perhaps, once the Astors had moved out of La Fayette Place, it became more a matter of how Americans generally thought of this French revolutionary figure. Among Americans today, he is overwhelmingly known and referred to as “Lafayette,” without a space, rather than “La Fayette.” Curiously, La Grange Terrace also lost its space after the “La” to become LaGrange Terrace.

In 1859, John Jacob Astor III moved to his new mansion on the corner of 33rd Street and Fifth Avenue, the site of the future Empire State Building. La Grange Terrace went into decline and his previous home at No. 424 La Grange Terrace was demolished in 1902 – leaving 4 houses still intact (428-434).

Given his visionary status in developing elevators, would John Jacob Astor III have been more surprised that some of La Grange Terrace still exist into the 21st century, or that his house on Fifth Avenue would be the spot of a 1,250 feet tall skyscraper made possible by Otis elevators?

 

References